Subscribe and Sign In Buttons

More Bad News for Elon Musk After X User’s Legal Challenge to Shadowban Prevails

July 14, 2024
2 mins read

Elon Musk’s X (formerly known as Twitter) has faced significant legal challenges this month, with the latest blow coming from a successful legal challenge against the company’s shadowbanning practices. PhD student Danny Mekić brought legal action against X for infringing on his rights under the EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA) and General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) after his account was shadowbanned without notification.

Details of the Case

Danny Mekić discovered that his X account had visibility restrictions applied after he shared a news article related to his research on the bloc’s proposal to scan citizens’ private messages for child sexual abuse material (CSAM). The restrictions led to his replies being hidden and his account not appearing in search suggestions. Mekić’s attempts to contact X directly were unsuccessful, prompting him to file legal claims in the Netherlands under the EU Small Claims process.

Legal Findings

On July 5, the court ruled in Mekić’s favor, finding that X’s Irish subsidiary violated several provisions of the DSA:

  • Article 12: Failing to provide a point of contact for complaints.
  • Article 17: Failing to provide a statement of reasons for the account restrictions.

Mekić, a premium subscriber to X, also sued for breach of contract and was awarded compensation for the service deprivation period. Additionally, the court ordered X to provide him with a point of contact within two weeks or face a daily fine of €100.

GDPR Violations

In a separate ruling on July 4, the court found X in violation of the GDPR, particularly:

  • Article 22: Automated decision-making affecting Mekić’s professional visibility and employment prospects.
  • Data access rights: X failed to provide personal information requested by Mekić.

The court ordered X to provide meaningful information about the automated decision-making and the withheld personal information within one month. Failure to comply could result in fines of up to €4,000 per day.

Wider Implications

These rulings could have broader implications for the enforcement of the DSA and GDPR against X. The DSA focuses on stricter content moderation, while the GDPR emphasizes data protection and transparency. Privacy campaigners have long argued for stronger enforcement of these regulations against major platforms.

Comments from Danny Mekić

Mekić expressed satisfaction with the rulings but emphasized the need for regulatory enforcement to address arbitrary shadowbanning comprehensively. He criticized X’s lack of transparency and commercial motives behind shadowbans, suggesting that platforms should impose transparent, contestable restrictions on users instead.

Regulatory Oversight

The enforcement of the DSA and GDPR falls to various regulatory bodies, including Ireland’s media regulator, Coimisiún na Meán, and the Data Protection Commission (DPC). However, these bodies have been criticized for their slow responses and limited enforcement actions against major tech platforms.

Conclusion

The legal victories for Danny Mekić highlight the challenges users face in holding major platforms accountable for their practices. While individual legal actions can set precedents, comprehensive regulatory enforcement is necessary to ensure transparency and compliance with EU laws. The outcomes of these cases may prompt further scrutiny of X’s practices and potentially lead to broader changes in how social media platforms manage content moderation and data protection.

Forbes Staff

Forbes Staff is an official member of the esteemed Forbes team, dedicated to delivering high-quality content and insightful journalism. With a deep understanding of the industry and a passion for uncovering compelling stories, Forbes Staff brings their expertise to the world of fashion. As a trusted member of the Forbes team, they contribute to the renowned Forbes platform, providing readers with valuable insights into the global fashion landscape.

Previous Story

Waymo Cameras Capture Footage of Person Charged in Alleged Robotaxi Tire Slashings

Next Story

Kudos Raises $3M for Healthier, Cotton-Based Disposable Diapers

Latest from Blog